The Myth of St Thomas and the Mylapore Shiva Temple › Ishwar Sharan › 2019

Martyrdom of St Thomas by Peter Paul Rubens

An updated (2019) version of The Myth of Saint Thomas and the Mylapore Shiva Temple is available to read on its own website at https://wp.me/PXz6v-5.

The Myth of Saint Thomas and the Mylapore Shiva Temple is a complete study of the St. Thomas in India legend—its origin, history, and communal ramifications—and is named after the main, 24-chapter essay by Ishwar Sharan. It includes many independent, penetrating articles by senior journalists and scholars, and exposes in detail the anti-Hindu bias in India’s secular English-language media. One chapter deals with the pronounced Christian bias of the Encyclopedia Britannica and popular online reference portal Wikipedia. Both encyclopedia’s carry fanciful, non-factual entries for St. Thomas the Apostle in India that they refuse to correct or change.

The book documents the destruction of the original Kapaleeswara Shiva Temple by the Portuguese and its replacement by the San Thome Cathedral Basilica on the Mylapore beach in Chennai.

Noted orientalist Dr. Koenraad Elst has written a comprehensive foreword for the new edition. His short foreword to the 1995 edition is posted below as an introduction of the book to new readers. He makes some pertinent remarks about Indian secularists and their uncritical acceptance of Christian mythology as Indian history.

Dr. Elst studied under Jesuits at Katholieke Universiteit in Belgium, Europe’s oldest Catholic university at Leuven,  and is in a position to say with authority that the St. Thomas in India tale is a fraud on the people of India by crafty, untruthful Catholic  priests who make their living by fooling the faithful. He writes:

Thomas of CanaAccording to Christian leaders in India, the apostle Thomas came to India in 52 AD, founded the Syrian Christian Church, and was killed by the fanatical Brahmins in 72 AD. Near the site of his martyrdom, the St. Thomas Church was built. In fact this apostle never came to India. The Christian community in South India was founded by a merchant called Knai Thoma or Thomas of Cana in 345 AD—a name which readily explains the Thomas legend. He led four hundred refugees who fled persecution in Persia and were given asylum by the Hindu authorities.

In Catholic universities in Europe, the myth of the apostle Thomas going to India is no longer taught as history, but in India it is still considered useful. Even many vocal “secularists” who attack the Hindus for “relying on myth” in the Ayodhya affair, off-hand profess their belief in the Thomas myth. The important point is that Thomas can be upheld as a martyr and the Brahmins decried as fanatics.

San Thome ChurchIn reality, the missionaries were very disgruntled that the damned Hindus refused to give them martyrs (whose blood is welcomed as “the seed of the faith”), so they had to invent one. Moreover, the church which they claim commemorates St.Thomas’s martyrdom at the hands of Hindu fanaticism, is in fact a monument of Hindu martyrdom at the hands of Christian fanaticism. It is a forcible replacement of two important Hindu temples — Jain and Shaiva—whose existence was insupportable to the Christian missionaries.

No one knows how many Hindu priests and worshipers were killed when the Christian soldiers came to remove the curse of Paganism from the Mylapore beach. Hinduism does not practice martyr-mongering, but if at all we have to speak of martyrs in this context, the title goes to these Jina- and Shiva-worshipers and not to the apostle Thomas

Copies of The Myth of Saint Thomas and the Mylapore Shiva Temple, Second Print Edition (1995) are available from  Voice of India, New Delhi.


1991 — The Myth of Saint Thomas and the Mylapore Shiva Temple — Ishwar Sharan

2019 — The Myth of Saint Thomas and the Mylapore Shiva Temple — Ishwar Sharan


Old Kapali Temple


 

Advertisements

14 Responses

  1. Dear Patriots,
    It’s my earnest request to you all why not translate every material in local language and distribute them to local papers just to increase the public awareness.That will be a great sewa[service to Sanatan Dharma].Instead of writing small comments for English speaking and reading computer literate Internet Hindus.
    Jai Hind! Vande Mataram!
    From:Dr R N Das

    • The local papers refuse to publish . the best way is to keep teeing who ever close and respect you and forward this mail to as many people u know.

      • Why not in translated in Tamil and publish on Facebook and Twitter..

        • Thank you for your interest in the book.

          There is a Tamil-language redaction of the main, 24-chapter essay of the 1995 edition of the book available on Scribd. See it HERE.

          There is also a Tamil-language study of the St. Thomas myth by Veda Prakash on Scrbd. See it HERE.

  2. eye opening blog,nice.i hope those secular hindu morons read these stuff.

  3. @ Sri Iswar Sharan Ji, My Regards And Respects To You. I Am Very Sincerely Glad To See Someone Working Selflessly Towards The Protection Of Sanatana Dharma. Our Country, Youth In General Are Being Misguided By These Invaders. It’s Thanks To Intelligent People Like You We Are Still Surviving. My Respects Again __/\__

  4. Read few articles found it very informative…thanks for the info…I’ll surely follow your blog…Keep the good work going….

  5. sanathana dharma was the way of life before these evil muslim maniacs attacked india for her wealth. There was no “Hindu’. When the larger part of the world was into plundering, war mongering it is a great wonder that a great experiment to unveil the secrets of consciousness was being carried by people in India. Such were the heights of excellence reached by our people that others were not even able to imagine what it was all about. Similar is the story of Einstein whose relativity theory was and is understood only by a very few. The whole experiment of Brahminism, where he is not to accumulate wealth and has to lead a pious life were all great arrangements to make him ponder into his own self. The mundane was stripped away. The society of those days understood the value of such a great adventure and more than willingly supported it. This is very much like the present R & D being supported by the government and big corporates. Then it was the king who supported the cause. Look at the results of such experiments. Ramana maharishi , J. Krishnamurti, Ramakrishna and many others reached to the state of great immensity. Even today in everyday life if there are ten brahmins, eight will be good. But the case is reverse in the case of others. Take muslims. Almost 90% of smugglers and people who engage in nefarious activities are muslims. I have been in the Madras airport many times. I have seen these muslim traders(smugglers) walking through green channel loaded with all kinds of goods. One cannot find a brahmin in the lot..Why go that far? In the news papers which cry hoarse for secularism like “The Hindu” one can see clearly that almost all smugglers are muslims. They are predominantly upto only cheating and if not checked they are going to pose a great threat to the country. .

  6. I also think that at least the educated youngsters should read books like The Jesus Discovery by James Tabor and others by same author. It informs that Jesus was only a local leader of a family of rulers called the Davids and he was crucified alongwith others as was the norm in the Roman world. He was a Jew, and led a traditional life with Mary his wife and brothers and children. In short, even if he did existed he was just a freedom fighter like maybe our Shahid Bhagat Singh. The author claims they found his tomb in Jerusalem. In later centuries some people lied and distorted the truth giving us the current distorted version. It is necessary for people to stop reading too much into all this foreign stuff. It is very childish and immature to keep idolising them needlessly just because they are rich nations. They think rich people’s Gods will make them rich if they pray to them. Instead of fighting for positions, HIndu religious leaders should spend more time teaching proper Hinduism. At least the well-informed HIndu should do this. Instead of planning vacations with family all the time, for example,at least once if they go to a poor area and sit and do some bhajan kirtan with the poor it can help the cause tremendously.

  7. it is a wonderful article and it has to be cerculate to all temple and mutts authorities of india since we are all already in a cloud of without facts and figures of our history. these semetic religions of the middle east made lot hawoke and unslaught on hidhus in our country and we have become already slaves and orphons in the hands of minority peopole of india even though we are in mejority. we hindhus who fought for independence never understood the meaning od independence. we are so unconscious of our self , socieal and nation conscious people. india has become no man;s lands and any body can come and rape of country. we are branded trhat india is spiritual country and the land of wisdom but the way india ia moving we are loosing the identeties of our country by our own people who are not loyal to the country and bfull of correuption in their mind , body and mind

  8. sri iswar sharan ji,

    i’m very happy to read your work.
    you’re the hope for hindus like us.

    please keep up the good work.

    i’m honoured,even to address you in this reply.

    Om Shanti,shanti,shanti

    • Thank you. You are very kind.

      • Thirukkural Sivam

        • Thirukkural Sivam

          This interview with Dharmapuram Adheenam highlights the Christian Conversion factory methods to distort Tamizh &…saivism.

          This is not a commercial venture or academic venture.

          This is a video of a concerned Hindu Journalist.

          The Objective was to defend a Saiva Mutt, which was unable to defend itself from a malicious propaganda unleashed by the Christian missionaries since 1986- A propaganda video produced by one Mr.Deivanayagam that purportedly declares a unilateral victory over the Hindu Mutt. The video was shot, doctored and sold across missionary counters and this is used missionary zealots and used as a propaganda tool against the Hindus.

          It was decades since the propaganda had been unleashed on the hapless mutt, by a loose Cannon-Evangelist. It was a one sided attack from which the mutt had no means recovery or defending themselves from the malicious propaganda using a doctored video.The myth of Thomas, has been covered by Ishwar sharan and others extensively but no video was ever made.

          “To Defend the Hindu Mutt that was unable to defend itself for the sake of Defense”,that started in 2007. Finished in 2019 against much hurdles . It is not funded or organized by the Mutt the subject .

          Nor was it funded by any organization or individual.

          It has nothing to election propaganda. It has taken 12 long years to bring it out on a shoe string budget.

          Ever since the DMK came to power in 1967, since the 1972, Christian missionaries have been deriving power from the state’s Dravidian ideology to further their cause.

          When in 2007 to find out the truth, the Senior Adheenams was in his eighties .We decided to meet the juniors who were highly knowledgeable by any standards.

          We had to have preparatory research and background information in advance before we went with the research. I met, many scholars connected with the mutt; obtain rare interviews and footage, old photos, conference pictures, which highlighted the intrusion plans of Deivanayagam a foot soldier of Christian Missionaries.

          Our researchers who also met many key people and obtained publications that referred to them, we also met the many books published by the Mutt.

          Since the issues are so much complicated we had to bring out the fraud in a story for a video audience.

          We found a grand plan of Missionaries that would later unfold in various levels, at the academic research, using the portals of Universities, dubious comparative research that would produce PhDs factories, in connivance with Vice Chancellors, compromised universities, driven by fanatical Dravidian ideology. The ideologues in positions of Power in the State, Politics; Police; Judiciary & Administration; that gave the missionaries a free run, and the much needed leverage, versus the virtual lack of power for Hindus.

          The Hindus of Tamilnadu, and Hindu Mutts on one side, and the state hand in hand with missionaries on the other side was an unequal playing field, with uneven rules and biased referee.

          This seemed to be vicious cycle. Hindu Bhaktas who are devoted to the Mutt, but were unable to fight back, due to fear and inferiority complex and lack of financial resources.

          All these needs are there even now. We have sought to fill up this vacuum with the single idea that that a rebuttal in video must come out from the Mutt side “for the sake of Posterity”. Also I felt it should be from the Horse’s mouth , the swamis of the mutt, to counter the propaganda video by a Christian Missionary.

          The propaganda runs like this evangelical went for a debate in a Saivite Mutt, and defeated the Swami or the head of the Mutt way back in 1986. The Swamis concerned had never heard of the Video.

          Even when the Saivite experts from the Mutt had published a rebuttal, in the form of Scholarly book, in 1991, but that was not supplemented or countered by a video rebuttal. The Christian Missionary was selling a doctored CD one that were sold all over, that Missionaries had a victory over the Mutt. Hindus were silent.

          This was the Hindu Predicament-how to give a rebuttal?

          We have given a fitting rebuttal to this fraud Deivanayagam. This video highlights the Christian conversion factory methods. It has taken 12 years produce, started in 2007 as a Documentary cum pet project; it could see the light of the day in 2019, Jan 15.

          Those who know Hindu Mutts, will vouch for the facts, that it is very Difficult to get interviews, that too uninterrupted, for hours. The mutt authorities have so many religious duties, poojas, and austerities. It is my fortune that I had uninterrupted time as well was allowed to do the recording on this complex subject.

          Here we seek to Highlight the Saivite side of the Issue, and present it in proper perspective to the world at large and especially Christian Donors and NGOs who fund these Missionaries.

          This is not a commercial venture or academic venture.

          This is a video of a concerned Hindu Journalist.

Comments are moderated

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: