What Hindu tradition says about evolution – Subhash Kak

Valmiki

Prof Subhash KakSuperstitions arise in the absence of right knowledge and sunlight dispels darkness. A course on history of Indian science in colleges and universities will go a long way in presenting Indian scientific ideas to the next generation. – Prof Subhash Kak

There was an outcry in the Indian media last week when Satyapal Singh, Minister of State for Human Resource Development, reportedly said: “Darwin’s theory (of evolution) is scientifically wrong. It needs to change in school and college curriculum. Since the man is seen on earth, he has always been a man.” He was speaking to reporters in Aurangabad at the All India Vaidik Sammelan.

He reportedly added: “Nobody—including our ancestors—has said they saw an ape turning into a man. No books we have read or the tales told to us by our grandparents had such a mention.”

Indian scientists are shocked that the minister should speak thus against the idea of evolution which is fundamental to biology and medicine. How can the HRD minister be so ill-informed about science? This is all the more puzzling since he was a senior police officer before entering politics.

Was the minister merely trying to be nice to the traditionalists at the Vaidik Sammelan, and he has no strong views on the matter, and perhaps the HRD ministry is safe under his leadership?

My own thinking is that he is genuinely misinformed because, in reality, the idea of evolution (more general than Darwinian Evolution) is basic to all Indian thought, which is something that he does not appear to know.

The least he can do is to understand both modern evolution theory and Indian ideas on it and then see how the education system in India can help people know the history of Indian ideas as well as the foundations of modern science.

Indian ideas on evolution

The Sankhya is the Indian theory of evolution, which is supposed to apply both to the individual and the cosmos. In it, the basic entities are pure consciousness and materiality (nature). Nature has three constituent qualities (gunas) called sattva, rajas, and tamas, and as the balance between these three changes the universe evolves.

Out of the interplay of the five basic elements arise other principles (tattva): five subtle elements, five action senses, five senses of perception, mind, egoity, and intellect. The evolutionary sequence goes through many levels. The tattvas help in the emergence of life out of inert matter. The gunas are not to be taken as abstract principles alone. Indian thought believes that structure in nature is recursive, and the gunas show up in various forms at different levels of expression.

The texts imply that ingredients for the growth of life are available throughout the universe. Infinite number of universes are conceived, so each new one is created like a bubble in an ocean of bubbles. The tattvas are not discrete and their varying expression creates the diversity of life in and across leading different species.

Each sensory and motor tattva is mapped into a corresponding organ. Indian thought conceives of 8.4 million species, which is an impressive number, considering modern authorities estimate the number of extant species to be 4.5-10 million.

Physicist Erwin Schrödinger thought that the Sankhyan tattvas were the most plausible model for the evolution of the sensory organs. A quote on evolution on earth from the thousand-year-old, encyclopedic Yoga Vasistha (YV):

I remember that once upon a time there was nothing on this earth, neither trees and plants, nor even mountains. For a period of eleven thousand years (4 million earth years) the earth was under lava…. [Later] apart from the polar region, the rest of the earth was covered by water. And then forests enveloped the earth, and great asuras (demons) ruled. Then there arose great mountains, but without any human inhabitants. For a period of ten thousand years (almost 4 million earth years) the earth was covered with the corpses of the asuras.

Indicating the presence of other animals while the giant asuras were on earth, YV suggests that man arose later. YV also speaks of minor ages of destruction on earth that correspond to the yugas.

The Indians believed that all life can be divided into three classes (Chandogya Upanishad 6.3.1): “In truth, beings have here three kinds of seeds, born from the egg, born alive, and born from the germ.”

Given that it is also affirmed that life on other planets exists and that there was a gradual rise of life on the earth, it would appear that this implied a belief in a panspermia theory.

Why aren’t Indian ideas on evolution known to educated Indians?

We see that Satyapal Singh did not need to deny evolution just to be on the right side of the remembered Indian tradition. The question then is: Why are the minister and other Indians ill-informed about their own sciences?

India is the only major nation where history of science is not integrated in the school and college curriculum. People pick up bits and pieces on it from a variety of sources, such as tangential references in religious texts, and other sources many of which are unreliable or plain wrong.

Superstitions arise in the absence of right knowledge and sunlight dispels darkness. A course on history of Indian science in colleges and universities will go a long way in presenting Indian scientific ideas to the next generation, and help people distinguish scientific ideas from mythology and fiction. The history of Indian science is not a politically divisive issue as it is not teaching religion or ritual. Why can’t the HRD ministry take leadership on this issue? –Daily-O, 22 January 2018

» Subhash Kak is a Vedic scholar and computer scientist. He is the Regents professor of electrical and computer engineering at Oklahoma State University. 

Evolution


 

Advertisements

5 Responses

  1. Whatever half baked logic you tried to established with a little bit of reference from here and there, please answer a simple question. The picture [the editor] has shown as evolution has 6 figures with first of a primate and the 6th of a human being. We can see both of them on the planet. Why don’t we see any of the rest of the four who should be in the process of transition of evolution. or has the evolution stopped after giving theory to Darwin. Certain things are quite obvious that we dare not believe them and would like to believe what has been given to us by the Gori chamri. Suggest me an indian scripture which clearly mentions this theory of evolution as given by darwin.

    • Scientists claim there is some evidence for the other four beings (look up the details yourself).

      The image was chosen because of the space between the fifth figure and the sixth. It represents the missing link, a common ancestor for the chimpanzee and human.

      Evolution is only scientific theory, even as theology is only religious theory.

      Both have yet to be proved factual.

      But that doesn’t mean either should be denied or ignored.

      What Hindu scholars have to say about evolution is very interesting and important—especially when idiot politicians mouth off about it and hog the headlines.

  2. Re: “India is the only major nation where history of science is not integrated in the school and college curriculum. People pick up bits and pieces on it from a variety of sources, such as tangential references in religious texts, and other sources many of which are unreliable or plain wrong.”

    Indeed.

    While even a small European country has this Centre for the Study of Indian Science:

    http://ccrs.ku.dk/research/centres-and-projects/csis/:

  3. Impressive. Tough to understand though. But one thing is clear. A scientific temper calls for eternal searching of relationships as much as did the ancient seekers of knowledge. Taking adamant positions on issues of knowledge is not the Indian way. It is always a jignaasa till the truth is experienced and one merges into.

Comments are moderated

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: