Letter to Manmohan Singh: Carla Bruni-Sonia Gandhi plane deal – Subramanian Swamy

Dr. Subramanian Swamy“I demand that you call for the review of the decision taken so far in the matter of purchase of aircrafts for the Indian Air Force. I would urge you to make this review as transparent as possible so that those of us who have technical expertise will give good inputs for you to come to a conclusion.” – Dr. Subramanian Swamy

April 29, 2011.

Dr. Manmohan Singh,
Prime Minister of India,
South Block, New Delhi.

Dear Prime Minister:

I made some enquiries from well placed sources in your Government regarding the decision already taken but not yet formalized (short of the ritual of commercial evaluation and index of performance criteria)– the choice of French planes for the Indian Air Force.

My sources indicate that the pre-determined decision to favour the French aircraft was the outcome of several conversations between the wife of French President Ms. Carla Bruni and the Chairperson of the National Advisory Council Ms. Sonia Gandhi, and surprisingly also with two foreign nationals who are the sisters of Ms. Sonia Gandhi.

Based on some credible information given to me on the conversation between Ms. Carla Bruni and Ms. Sonia Gandhi’s sisters, there has been an agreement of the French to pay a hefty bribe for favouring the [Rs 40,000 crore] purchase of French aircrafts. This, if documented in the future, will be a major scandal which will haunt you and may lead to criminal prosecution for no fault of yours except that you have been compliant to the mysterious system of governance in this country that has been worked out by Ms. Sonia Gandhi since 2004. The Defence Minister Mr. A.K. Antony is like you, personally honest but he is even more compliant to these rules of governance. Hence I am sending a copy of this letter to him.

Therefore you should take necessary steps to see that you are not kept out of the loop, as had been the case in the 2G Himalayan scam. The US aircraft which has been deleted from the shortlist may or may not be the best for our Air Force (it has to be determined by your experts), but the US has a Foreign Corrupt Practices Act which makes it almost impossible to give bribes. The French, however, while dealing with a foreign country have a much more relaxed attitude to bribes paid abroad to secure contracts and this attitude has become a part of their mental makeup of contempt for the foreigner, especially us Indians.

Therefore I demand that you call for the review of the decision taken so far in the matter of purchase of aircrafts for the Indian Air Force. I would urge you to make this review as transparent as possible so that those of us who have technical expertise will give good inputs for you to come to a conclusion.

Yours sincerely,

SUBRAMANIAN SWAMY 

» NB: This letter is not posted on the Janata Party website. However Dr. Swamy has verified this letter by email. – IS 

8 Responses

  1. It may sound little disappointing tone of the comments but Indian citizens have very short memory.The people of India forgets very quickly.This Italian lady has come to India to suck India as a very strategic game plan of western country.

  2. He is right that there is a strong rumor about the above mentioned deal between Sonia and Carla. I heard this in defence circles in France. However, I also feel that Rafale is indeed the better of the two planes in the final stage of MMRCA. Rafale is better than EF. That is my view based on my experience and knowledge of this industry.

  3. Do you have the link for the original letter? I mean, the source?

    thks,

    • Usually these letters are posted on the Janata Party website at http://janataparty.org/press.asp.

      For some reason this one is not posted there. We are trying to verify the source of the letter now.

      • Dr. Swamy has just verified by email that he has written this letter to PM Manmohan Singh.

        Watch his website at http://janataparty.org/press.asp. The letter will appear there eventually.

        • The letter sounds very credible to me, but is very important to have the original source.

          I’ll check Janata’s site out once in a while.

          Thanks!

          • Dr. Swamy has asked his staff to post the letter on the Janata Party website. Pls watch the website. It may take a few days.

            I agree with you that such letters must be verifiable. Thanks for your interest.

  4. […] would think so and now the alleged news of the French aircrafts for India with the Italian connections as brokers has erupted. In France as well as in India the Italian connection is strong and thus Mrs. Sonia […]

Comments are moderated

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: